CraftKilnTested Craft Supplies
Independent · Hands-on · Since 2021

Craft supplies, tested before you trust them.

We put 57 paints, papers, pens, tools and machines through real studio projects — so you can fill your cart with confidence, not marketing hype.

57Products tested
51Brands compared
33Categories
A maker's studio workbench
Real
studio
testing
Brands we've tested
Aleene'sAmerican CraftsArtezaBrotherCansonCloverCopicCrayolaCricutDecoArtDerwentElmer'sFaber-CastellFabrianoFiskarsFolkArtGeneral'sGoldenGorillaGutermannLion BrandLiquitexLoctiteLoew-CornellMEIYIQIMartha Stewart CraftsMelissa & DougMod PodgeMolotowPerlerPoscaPrangPrincetonPrismacolorRecollectionsRed HeartRoyal & LangnickelSakuraScotchSharpieSilhouetteSingerStaedtlerStrathmoreSusan BatesTombowUS Art SupplyWe R Memory KeepersWinsor & NewtonX-ACTOYasutomoAleene'sAmerican CraftsArtezaBrotherCansonCloverCopicCrayolaCricutDecoArtDerwentElmer'sFaber-CastellFabrianoFiskarsFolkArtGeneral'sGoldenGorillaGutermannLion BrandLiquitexLoctiteLoew-CornellMEIYIQIMartha Stewart CraftsMelissa & DougMod PodgeMolotowPerlerPoscaPrangPrincetonPrismacolorRecollectionsRed HeartRoyal & LangnickelSakuraScotchSharpieSilhouetteSingerStaedtlerStrathmoreSusan BatesTombowUS Art SupplyWe R Memory KeepersWinsor & NewtonX-ACTOYasutomo
Editors' Top Picks

Three supplies we reach for first

Awarded by our review desk after hands-on testing across every category.

Best for BeginnersCricut Explore Air 2
Cutting Machine

Cricut Explore Air 2

★★★★☆4.5/5

A friendly gateway into cutting machines — quick setup, cuts 100+ materials, forgiving for first projects.

Read the review →
Head to head

Top 5 compared

Our five standout performers, scored side by side. Tap any row for the full review.

ProductRatingQualityValue
1
Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils 150 CountPrismacolor Premier Colored Pencils 150 CountColored Pencils
4.8 /5Quality 97
Value 92
Check price
2
Cricut Maker 3Cricut Maker 3Cutting Machine
4.7 /5Quality 93
Value 93
Check price
3
Copic Sketch Markers 72 Color SetCopic Sketch Markers 72 Color SetMarkers
4.7 /5Quality 94
Value 80
Check price
4
Golden Heavy Body AcrylicsGolden Heavy Body AcrylicsAcrylic Paint
4.7 /5Quality 94
Value 95
Check price
5
Winsor Newton Professional Watercolor SetWinsor Newton Professional Watercolor SetWatercolor Paint
4.7 /5Quality 93
Value 91
Check price
The full catalog

Browse all 57 reviews

Filter by craft to find your next supply.

Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils 150 Count4.8
Colored Pencils

Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils 150 Count

  • 150 vibrant shades
  • Smooth blendable pigment
  • Durable break-resistant cores
Read review →
Aleene S Tacky Glue4.7
Glue

Aleene S Tacky Glue

  • Instant tacky grip
  • Dries crystal clear
  • Versatile multi-surface bond
Read review →
Clover Amour Crochet Hooks Set4.7
Crochet Supplies

Clover Amour Crochet Hooks Set

  • Ergonomic comfort grip
  • Complete organized hook set
  • Reduces hand fatigue
Read review →
Copic Sketch Markers 72 Color Set4.7
Markers

Copic Sketch Markers 72 Color Set

  • Refillable long-lasting markers
  • Smooth professional blending
  • 72 curated color palette
Read review →
Crayola Crayons 64 Count Box4.7
Crayons

Crayola Crayons 64 Count Box

  • 64 vivid colors
  • Built-in sharpener included
  • Trusted classroom staple
Read review →
Cricut Maker 34.7
Cutting Machine

Cricut Maker 3

  • Cuts 300+ materials
  • Matless cutting up to 12ft
  • Fast wireless performance
Read review →
Faber Castell Polychromos Colored Pencils4.7
Colored Pencils

Faber Castell Polychromos Colored Pencils

  • Archival lightfast pigments
  • Smooth oil-based blending
  • Break-resistant sharpenable core
Read review →
General S Kimberly Drawing Pencils4.7
Graphite Pencils

General S Kimberly Drawing Pencils

  • Smooth consistent shading
  • Wide degree range
  • Break-resistant graphite core
Read review →
Golden Heavy Body Acrylics4.7
Acrylic Paint

Golden Heavy Body Acrylics

  • Rich pigment saturation
  • Holds sculptural texture
  • Archival lightfast quality
Read review →
Sakura Pigma Micron Pens Set4.7
Fine Liner Pens

Sakura Pigma Micron Pens Set

  • Archival fade-resistant ink
  • Multiple precise nib sizes
  • Smear-proof waterproof lines
Read review →
Sharpie Permanent Markers 24 Pack4.7
Markers

Sharpie Permanent Markers 24 Pack

  • Long-lasting vivid ink
  • Fine point precision
  • Bulk value pack
Read review →
Staedtler Mars Lumograph Pencils4.7
Graphite Pencils

Staedtler Mars Lumograph Pencils

  • Smooth consistent shading
  • Wide grade selection
  • Break-resistant graphite core
Read review →
Tombow Dual Brush Pens 96 Color Set4.7
Brush Pens

Tombow Dual Brush Pens 96 Color Set

  • 96 vibrant blendable colors
  • Dual brush and fine tips
  • Smooth watercolor-style blending
Read review →
Winsor Newton Professional Watercolor Set4.7
Watercolor Paint

Winsor Newton Professional Watercolor Set

  • Artist-grade pigment intensity
  • Portable studio-to-field case
  • Reliable rewetting performance
Read review →
American Crafts Cardstock Pack4.6
Cardstock

American Crafts Cardstock Pack

  • Archival-safe paper quality
  • Heavyweight, warp-resistant sheets
  • Versatile coordinating color palette
Read review →
Crayola Washable Markers 40 Count4.6
Markers

Crayola Washable Markers 40 Count

  • 40 vibrant colors
  • Easy washable cleanup
  • Kid-friendly comfort grip
Read review →
Derwent Inktense Pencils4.6
Colored Pencils

Derwent Inktense Pencils

  • Ink-based pigment intensity
  • Permanent once dry
  • Ideal for mixed media
Read review →
Elmer S School Glue4.6
Glue

Elmer S School Glue

  • Washable and non-toxic
  • Dries crystal clear
  • Trusted classroom staple
Read review →
Fiskars Rotary Cutter4.6
Fabric Cutting Tools

Fiskars Rotary Cutter

  • Ergonomic comfort grip
  • Precise clean cuts
  • Retractable safety guard
Read review →
Gutermann Sew All Thread Set4.6
Sewing Thread

Gutermann Sew All Thread Set

  • Reliable stitch strength
  • Wide color selection
  • Low-lint smooth finish
Read review →
Lion Brand Wool Ease Yarn4.6
Yarn

Lion Brand Wool Ease Yarn

  • Soft wool blend feel
  • Machine washable convenience
  • Great stitch definition
Read review →
Melissa Doug Bead Set4.6
Beading Craft

Melissa Doug Bead Set

  • Boosts fine motor skills
  • Durable wooden beads
  • Includes tidy storage box
Read review →
Mod Podge Gloss Sealer Glue4.6
Decoupage Glue

Mod Podge Gloss Sealer Glue

  • All-in-one glue and sealer
  • Glossy glass-like finish
  • Non-toxic and easy cleanup
Read review →
Molotow One4All Acrylic Markers4.6
Paint Markers

Molotow One4All Acrylic Markers

  • Refillable acrylic system
  • True spray-paint color match
  • Interchangeable nib sizes
Read review →
Perler Beads Bucket 11000 Count4.6
Beading Craft

Perler Beads Bucket 11000 Count

  • Massive 11000-bead supply
  • Reusable storage bucket
  • Great for group crafts
Read review →
Posca Paint Markers 8 Set4.6
Paint Markers

Posca Paint Markers 8 Set

  • Opaque multi-surface coverage
  • Reversible until dry
  • Vibrant 8-color set
Read review →
Princeton Velvetouch Brush Set4.6
Paint Brushes

Princeton Velvetouch Brush Set

  • Multi-medium versatility
  • Soft yet resilient fibers
  • Reliable paint load
Read review →
Silhouette Cameo 44.6
Cutting Machine

Silhouette Cameo 4

  • Cuts fabric leather vinyl
  • Draw and cut simultaneously
  • Matless roll cutting
Read review →
X Acto Knife Set4.6
Craft Knives

X Acto Knife Set

  • Precision blade control
  • Quick blade swaps
  • Organized safe storage
Read review →
Arteza Acrylic Paint Set 60 Colors4.5
Acrylic Paint

Arteza Acrylic Paint Set 60 Colors

  • 60 vibrant colors included
  • Rich, long-lasting pigmentation
  • Easy water-based cleanup
Read review →
Cricut Explore Air 24.5
Cutting Machine

Cricut Explore Air 2

  • Cuts 100+ materials
  • Fast cutting mode
  • Bluetooth wireless setup
Read review →
Decoart Americana Acrylic Paint4.5
Acrylic Paint

Decoart Americana Acrylic Paint

  • Rich pigment coverage
  • 200+ matched colors
  • Easy soap-water cleanup
Read review →
Fiskars Paper Trimmer4.5
Paper Cutting Tools

Fiskars Paper Trimmer

  • Precise straight cuts
  • Safer blade design
  • Compact craft tool
Read review →
Fiskars Softgrip Scissors4.5
Scissors

Fiskars Softgrip Scissors

  • Comfortable non-slip grip
  • Precision stainless steel blades
  • Great for everyday crafts
Read review →
Gorilla Glue Clear4.5
Glue

Gorilla Glue Clear

  • Dries perfectly clear
  • No mess application
  • Strong versatile bond
Read review →
Liquitex Basics Acrylic Paint Set4.5
Acrylic Paint

Liquitex Basics Acrylic Paint Set

  • Budget-friendly full palette
  • Smooth easy blending
  • Fast-drying finish
Read review →
Loctite Craft Hobby Glue4.5
Glue

Loctite Craft Hobby Glue

  • Dries crystal clear
  • Precision fine-tip control
  • Safe photo-safe formula
Read review →
Loew Cornell Paint Brush Set4.5
Paint Brushes

Loew Cornell Paint Brush Set

  • Versatile brush shapes
  • Durable long-lasting bristles
  • Comfortable ergonomic handles
Read review →
Scotch Double Sided Tape4.5
Adhesive Tape

Scotch Double Sided Tape

  • Invisible clean bond
  • Acid-free photo safe
  • Easy tear application
Read review →
Strathmore 400 Series Drawing Pad4.5
Sketchbooks & Paper

Strathmore 400 Series Drawing Pad

  • Versatile dry-media surface
  • Acid-free archival paper
  • Reliable studio staple
Read review →
We R Memory Keepers Cinch Binding Tool4.5
Bookbinding Tools

We R Memory Keepers Cinch Binding Tool

  • Flat-lying page binding
  • Sturdy metal construction
  • Professional book-like finish
Read review →
Winsor Newton Cotman Watercolor Set4.5
Watercolor Paint

Winsor Newton Cotman Watercolor Set

  • Rich pigment saturation
  • Compact travel design
  • Budget-friendly quality
Read review →
Arteza Watercolor Pencils 72 Color4.4
Colored Pencils

Arteza Watercolor Pencils 72 Color

  • 72 vivid shades
  • Dry-to-wet versatility
  • Portable easel case
Read review →
Brother Xm2701 Sewing Machine4.4
Sewing Machines

Brother Xm2701 Sewing Machine

  • Beginner-friendly setup
  • 27 built-in stitches
  • Lightweight & portable
Read review →
Fabriano Watercolor Paper Pad4.4
Watercolor Paper

Fabriano Watercolor Paper Pad

  • Heritage Italian papermaking
  • Cold-press textured surface
  • Portable bound pad
Read review →
Folkart Acrylic Paint Set4.4
Acrylic Paint

Folkart Acrylic Paint Set

  • Vibrant multi-surface color
  • Quick-drying matte finish
  • Easy water cleanup
Read review →
Martha Stewart Crafts Punch Set4.4
Paper Punches

Martha Stewart Crafts Punch Set

  • Intricate decorative punches
  • Professional card-making results
  • Compact organized storage
Read review →
Red Heart Super Saver Yarn4.4
Yarn

Red Heart Super Saver Yarn

  • Budget-friendly bulk yarn
  • Huge color variety
  • Machine washable durability
Read review →
Royal Langnickel Brush Set4.4
Paint Brushes

Royal Langnickel Brush Set

  • Versatile brush shapes
  • Comfortable ergonomic handles
  • Great value pricing
Read review →
Susan Bates Knitting Needles Set4.4
Knitting Supplies

Susan Bates Knitting Needles Set

  • Multiple sizes included
  • Smooth aluminum finish
  • Compact storage case
Read review →
Washi Tape Set 60 Rolls4.4
Decorative Tape

Washi Tape Set 60 Rolls

  • 60 unique patterns
  • Easy tear design
  • Great gift option
Read review →
Yasutomo Origami Paper Pack4.4
Origami Paper

Yasutomo Origami Paper Pack

  • Crisp reliable folds
  • Vibrant assorted patterns
  • Great value pack
Read review →
Canson Xl Series Mixed Media Pad4.3
Sketchbooks & Paper

Canson Xl Series Mixed Media Pad

  • Handles multiple media
  • Clean tear-out pages
  • Budget-friendly versatility
Read review →
Prang Watercolor Paint Set4.3
Watercolor Paint

Prang Watercolor Paint Set

  • Vivid blendable colors
  • Classroom-friendly value
  • Easy water reactivation
Read review →
Recollections Scrapbook Album4.3
Scrapbooking

Recollections Scrapbook Album

  • Expandable page capacity
  • Lay-flat design
  • Durable protective cover
Read review →
Singer Sewing Machine Simple 32324.3
Sewing Machines

Singer Sewing Machine Simple 3232

  • Beginner-friendly design
  • Automatic needle threader
  • Sturdy metal frame
Read review →
Us Art Supply Easel Stand4.3
Easels

Us Art Supply Easel Stand

  • Adjustable height design
  • Folds for easy storage
  • Sturdy wood build
Read review →
57Products tested
51Brands compared
33Categories covered
100%Hands-on reviews
How we test

The same honest process, every time

No marketing claims taken at face value — just practical guidance you can trust before you spend.

01

Quality & Durability

We check build quality and material consistency — paper weight, pigment load, tool construction — and how each holds up over repeated use.

02

Performance in Use

Our reviewers actually create with each product, judging blending, coverage and ease for beginners and pros alike.

03

Value for Money

We weigh price against what you really get, comparing like-for-like within each category across budgets.

04

Everyday Practicality

Packaging, storage, cleanup and beginner-friendliness all count — a great supply has to fit a real routine.

Buyer's guide

Frequently asked questions

How do I pick the right supplies for my skill level?

Beginners are usually best served by starter sets or budget-friendly picks that let you practice without a big investment, while experienced makers can prioritise the features and specs that support finer control. The highlights and pros/cons on each review help you match an item to where you are now.

What's the difference between student-grade and artist-grade materials?

Student-grade supplies are made to be affordable and forgiving for practice; artist-grade materials emphasise pigment quality and consistency for finished work. The right choice depends on your budget, how often you create, and whether you're practising or producing pieces to keep or sell.

Should I buy individual items or a full set?

Sets are a convenient way to build a rounded collection in one purchase, especially when starting out. Buying individually lets you focus on the exact colours, tools or materials you use most. Check each review's specs to see what's included before deciding.

How much does brand reputation matter?

Established brands often have more consistent quality control, but newer names can offer great value. Weigh the rating, pros and cons we list alongside the brand rather than relying on the name alone.

How should I store my art and craft supplies?

Most supplies last longer kept away from direct heat, moisture and sunlight, in their original packaging or a dedicated case. Always follow any product-specific guidance — paints, adhesives and papers each have different needs.

Is it worth reading reviews before buying?

Yes — the ratings, highlights and pros/cons throughout CraftKiln give a clearer picture of real-world performance before you commit, especially for pricier or specialised items.